Online retailer fines couple for negative review - KMSP-TV

Online retailer fines couple for negative review

Posted: Updated:
NEW YORK (MYFOXNY) -

A Utah couple faces a $3,500 fine and a tarnished credit rating after posting a negative review of an online retailer.

It all started in 2008 when John Palmer tried to buy his wife a Christmas gift from KlearGear.com. When KlearGear.com did not deliver the desk ornament and the site canceled the small transaction, Jen Palmer wrote an unflattering review on RipoffReport.com.

Nothing happened until 2012 when the site contacted the Palmers and demanded the $3,500 because of a non-disparagement clause that it said were included in the site's Terms of Use.

A consumer group that is fighting for the Palmers says that clause was actually not even on the website in 2008 and even if it had been, John Palmer did not write the negative review.

The Palmers refused to pay the fine so KlearGear.com reported the non-payment to at least one credit reporting agency. When the Palmers disputed that debt with credit reporting agencies, KlearGear.com continued to maintain that the debt was owed and also demanded payment of a $50 Dispute Fee.

The family claims that they were then denied credit for a new furnace when their old one broke. They also say they had difficulty getting a lender for a car loan in December of 2012 because of the negative report on John Palmer's credit. They say they were even denied a new credit card.

Public Citizen is the consumer group fighting on behalf of the Palmers. It is asking the company contact the credit agencies and any debt collectors related to the matter to report that they were "in error" and pay the Palmers $75,000 for their troubles. It also wants KlearGear.com to agree to not include a "non-disparagement" clause in its Terms of Use. The group says that if the company does not agree to those terms by Dec. 16, 2013, it will sue and ask for punitive damages.

KlearGear.com has not commented on the potential suit.

  • Your MoneyMore>>

  • NYC Denny's features $300 breakfast

    NYC Denny's features $300 breakfast

    Friday, August 29 2014 4:04 PM EDT2014-08-29 20:04:13 GMT
    Diner chain Denny's is opening it's first New York City location, complete with a big-city "deal".   How does a $300 breakfast sound?    The Denny's is located at the corner of Nassau and Spruce in Lower Manhattan's Financial District.  Along with its normal food you can get at just about any location in the rest of the country, this location will offer a Grand Slam breakfast with a bottle of 2003 Dom Perignon champagne.
    Diner chain Denny's is opening it's first New York City location, complete with a big-city "deal".   How does a $300 breakfast sound?    The Denny's is located at the corner of Nassau and Spruce in Lower Manhattan's Financial District.  Along with its normal food you can get at just about any location in the rest of the country, this location will offer a Grand Slam breakfast with a bottle of 2003 Dom Perignon champagne.
  • Some Showboat workers get new jobs within company

    Some Showboat workers get new jobs within company

    Friday, August 29 2014 2:54 PM EDT2014-08-29 18:54:36 GMT
    More than 470 of the 2,000-plus workers at Atlantic City's Showboat Casino Hotel have found new jobs with other casinos owned by its parent company. The Showboat is shutting down Sunday afternoon after 27 years on the Boardwalk.
    More than 470 of the 2,000-plus workers at Atlantic City's Showboat Casino Hotel have found new jobs with other casinos owned by its parent company. The Showboat is shutting down Sunday afternoon after 27 years on the Boardwalk.
  • Teens want back-to-school gadgets, not clothes

    Teens want back-to-school gadgets, not clothes

    Thursday, August 28 2014 9:52 PM EDT2014-08-29 01:52:52 GMT
    For many students, school starts next week. So what will your teens be asking you to buy? Technology.That's right: they are willing to wear last year's clothes and instead spend money on the latest tech. Gone are the days of securing your status in high school with the right clothes. Now your teens need to own the newest tablet or smart phone and its accessories.
    For many students, school starts next week. So what will your teens be asking you to buy? Technology.That's right: they are willing to wear last year's clothes and instead spend money on the latest tech. Gone are the days of securing your status in high school with the right clothes. Now your teens need to own the newest tablet or smart phone and its accessories.
Powered by WorldNow

KMSP-TV
11358 Viking Drive
Eden Prairie, MN 55344

Phone: (952) 944-9999
Fax: (952) 942-0455

Didn't find what you were looking for?
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Fox Television Stations, Inc. and Worldnow. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | New Terms of Service What's new | Ad Choices